INS-0010 · First-automation selection map

Check the gates first. Then compare the candidates.

Choosing the first automation takes two distinct steps. First, confirm that the process is manageable, measurable and recoverable. Only then use the score to compare it with other candidates.

From candidate process to field pilot

  1. Inventory processes
  2. Check the gates
  3. Compare 0–3
  4. Select
  5. Run a pilot
  6. Collect evidence
01

Check four essential conditions

If even one is missing, the process is not ready to enter the scored comparison.

  1. Condition 01One accountable owner

    Owns the outcome and decides whether to proceed or stop.

  2. Condition 02A defined outcome and baseline

    You know what “correct” means and can measure current performance.

  3. Condition 03Containable, recoverable errors

    You can detect, stop and correct errors before they cause serious harm.

  4. Condition 04Available, controlled data

    Data quality, access, privacy and security are managed in proportion to the risk.

Redesign the process

If one condition is missing, narrow the scope or fix the process. A high score cannot compensate for this blocker.

4 conditionsmet
02

Compare only eligible processes

Score each criterion from 0 to 3 and record why you chose that value.

  1. 01Repeated workload
  2. 02Value of the outcome
  3. 03Process clarity and stability
  4. 04Input quality and availability
  5. 05Exceptions and human judgement
  6. 06Error visibility and recovery
  7. 07Delivery effort
  8. Score for each criterion0 · 1 · 2 · 3
Maximum total: 21The total supports comparison; it is not an automatic approval threshold. Weighting depends on context.
Two minimum checksIf criterion 05 or 06 scores below 2, the process is not yet suitable as a first pilot.
When totals tieChoose the process with lower consequences, less delivery effort and faster feedback.

M4TIC prioritisation aid, not a validated universal model. Adapt the decision to the operating context.